Why does verification come first?
Because every other step in your response process executes faithfully on whatever gets past intake. Legal review checks whether the request is valid, not whether the requester is real. Production sends the data wherever the request said to send it. If the person on the other end is a criminal with a hacked police account, the rest of your process works perfectly on their behalf.
That’s not hypothetical. Apple, Meta, Discord, and Verizon have all handed user data to criminals through forged emergency requests. In November 2024, the FBI warned that compromised government email credentials from more than two dozen countries were for sale on criminal forums, marketed for exactly this. How fake EDRs work. The short version: forged requests are now cheap, packaged, and sold as a service.
Verification is the one step positioned to catch them, because it’s the only step that asks about the requester instead of the request.
For the attack behind those requests, see law enforcement email compromise.