A company that answers requests for user data makes decisions all day. The audit trail is the written account of those decisions, kept request by request and in the order they happened.
What a complete trail contains
For each request, a complete trail has an entry for every step, and each entry carries a timestamp and the name of the person who acted:
- Receipt of the request, the channel it came through and the person who logged it
- Verification of the requester, with the checks made and the result
- Classification of the instrument and the review of its scope
- Approval, narrowing or refusal, with the reviewer’s name and reason
- Production: what was sent, in what form, to whom and when
- Any notice to the account holder, or the non-disclosure condition that blocked it
What the trail is used for
A regulator or court that asks about a past disclosure gets its answer from the trail. It shows what the company received, who looked at it and what the company did.
The same record backs up a decision to refuse or narrow a request, since it shows the reasons given at the time. It supplies the counts for a public transparency report, and it lets a security team review who has accessed request data.
US law gives a provider a defence that depends on what it relied on. Under 18 U.S.C. § 2707(e), good-faith reliance on a court warrant or order, a grand jury subpoena, a legislative authorization or a statutory authorization is a complete defence to a civil or criminal action under the Stored Communications Act. The trail holds the document the provider received and the review that followed.
What makes a trail trustworthy
- Written by the system. Entries are created as actions happen.
- Append-only. Entries can be added and none can be edited or deleted.
- Attributable. Every entry names a person or a service account.
- Retained. The trail is kept for a set period that the company has chosen and written down.
Audit trail and chain of custody
Both are records of handling. Chain of custody is the record of how a piece of evidence was handled from collection onward. The audit trail records the decisions made on a request.
| Audit trail | Chain of custody | |
|---|---|---|
| What it follows | The decisions made on a request | The evidence itself |
| Question it answers | Who decided what, and on what basis? | Is this the same data that was collected, unaltered? |
| Who reads it | Regulators, courts, internal reviewers and the team preparing a report | Courts and parties testing the evidence |
| When it starts | When the request arrives | When the data is collected |