Agencies reach companies in different ways. A prosecutor serves a subpoena for subscriber records, and police responding to an emergency ask for a phone’s location while someone’s life is at risk. The umbrella term for every one of these is a law enforcement data request, and the kind of request decides how much legal weight it carries. Legal process is the part of that field that compels.
In the United States, two sections of chapter 121 of title 18 do most of the work. Section 2703 sets out how a governmental entity can require a provider to disclose stored contents and records, and to preserve them. Section 2702 sets out when a provider is permitted to disclose without being compelled.
The main kinds of request
- Compulsory legal process. A subpoena, a court order under 18 U.S.C. § 2703(d) or a search warrant. Section 2703 matches each instrument to the data it reaches.
- Preservation requests. Under § 2703(f), a provider asked by a governmental entity takes all necessary steps to preserve records pending a court order or other process. The records are retained for 90 days, extended for another 90 days on a renewed request.
- Emergency requests. Sections 2702(b)(8) and 2702(c)(4) permit a provider to disclose contents or records to a governmental entity when it believes in good faith that an emergency involving danger of death or serious physical injury requires disclosure without delay. See emergency disclosure requests.
- Cross-border requests. A foreign authority reaches a US provider through a mutual legal assistance treaty or through an order under an executive agreement that meets 18 U.S.C. § 2523, which §§ 2702(b)(9) and 2702(c)(7) permit the provider to answer. Inside the EU, a European Production Order goes directly to the provider.
| What it is | Compulsory? | |
|---|---|---|
| Subpoena | A demand for records. It reaches the basic subscriber information listed in § 2703(c)(2). | Yes |
| Court order | A judge’s order under § 2703(d), issued on specific and articulable facts. | Yes |
| Search warrant | A judge’s order issued on probable cause under Fed. R. Crim. P. 41(d). | Yes |
| Preservation request | A request under § 2703(f) to hold records. Nothing is produced. | Yes, as to the hold |
| Emergency disclosure request | A request for disclosure without delay under § 2702(b)(8) or (c)(4). | No, the provider decides |
What every request has to establish
Whatever its kind, a request gives the receiving company four questions to answer before it discloses anything.
- Who is asking. The agency exists and the person who sent the request works there.
- Under what authority. The request names an instrument and the statute or rule behind it, and an official empowered to issue that instrument signed it.
- For what data. The accounts, date range and data categories fall within what that instrument reaches.
- By when. A subpoena states a compliance date. A preservation hold under § 2703(f) runs for 90 days.
How a company handles one
- Intake. The request is received and logged with its sender, its date and the instrument it claims to be.
- Verification. The company confirms who sent it, using requester verification that does not rely on the contact details printed in the request.
- Review. The company classifies the instrument, checks that its scope matches the law, and notes any deadline.
- Production. The company discloses the data the instrument reaches, to the verified requester.
- Record. The company keeps a written account of what it received, what it decided and what it produced.