A voluntary disclosure has no subpoena, order or warrant behind it. The provider discloses because an exception in § 2702 applies, and the statute leaves the decision to the provider.
The general bar in section 2702(a)
Section 2702(a) of the Stored Communications Act bars a provider that serves the public from knowingly divulging the contents of communications it stores. It also bars the provider from divulging a record or other information pertaining to a subscriber to any governmental entity. Subsections (b) and (c) carry the exceptions.
The exceptions
- Consent. Contents can be disclosed with the lawful consent of the originator, an addressee or intended recipient, or the subscriber for remote computing service (§ 2702(b)(3)). Records can be disclosed with the lawful consent of the customer or subscriber (§ 2702(c)(2)).
- Reports to NCMEC. Contents and records can go to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children in connection with a report submitted under 18 U.S.C. § 2258A (§ 2702(b)(6) and (c)(5)).
- Contents obtained inadvertently. A provider can disclose contents to a law enforcement agency if it obtained them inadvertently and they appear to pertain to the commission of a crime (§ 2702(b)(7)).
- Records to a private party. Section 2702(c)(6) permits disclosure of records to any person other than a governmental entity.
- Emergencies. Sections 2702(b)(8) and 2702(c)(4) are covered below.
| Compelled disclosure | Voluntary disclosure | |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 18 U.S.C. § 2703 | 18 U.S.C. § 2702(b) and (c) |
| Trigger | A subpoena, court order or warrant | An exception applies |
| Who decides | The court or agency that issued the instrument | The provider |
| Standard | Set by the instrument, from a subpoena up to probable cause | For an emergency, a good-faith belief that danger of death or serious physical injury requires disclosure without delay |
| Example | A warrant for the contents of an account | A disclosure to a governmental entity in an emergency |
The emergency exception
Under § 2702(b)(8), a provider can disclose communications relating to the emergency to a governmental entity if it believes in good faith that an emergency involving danger of death or serious physical injury to any person requires disclosure without delay. Section 2702(c)(4) uses the same standard for information relating to the emergency. An emergency disclosure request asks the provider to use this exception. No judge reviews the request, so the provider’s own check of who is asking carries the weight.
Under § 2702(d), the Attorney General reports to the House and Senate Judiciary Committees each year on the number of accounts from which the Department of Justice has received voluntary disclosures under (b)(8) and (c)(4).
Why the decision and the record sit with the provider
With no instrument to point to, the provider is the only party that can show the exception applied, and its own record of the decision is that evidence. A disclosure outside the exceptions falls under the § 2702(a) bar. Under § 2707(a), a subscriber aggrieved by a violation committed with a knowing or intentional state of mind can bring a civil action, and § 2707(c) sets damages of at least $1,000 for a plaintiff entitled to recover.