Who pays when the government compels the work
Brad Brooker, General Counsel at Kodex, gave this account on stage at the keynote on October 27, 2026. The term for a company being reimbursed for the cost of answering legal process is cost recovery. Brad began with the history, which he said “goes back in the US over 50 years.”
Brad traces it to the Wiretap Act, which Congress enacted in 1968. An amendment two years later said a company compelled to provide facilities or technical assistance would be compensated. Almost two decades after that, Congress passed the Electronic Communications Privacy Act and, with it, the Stored Communications Act. Under that law, Brad said, a government entity that obtains data pays a fee, in most cases, to cover the provider’s reasonably necessary costs.
“I could find little in the record that says why Congress wrote the reimbursement provision into the law,” he said.
“It’s fair to presume lawmakers appreciated what responding would cost companies and wanted to cover part of it.”
Brad Brooker, General Counsel, Kodex
The picture abroad
Outside the US, Brad called the picture uneven. In his account, the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act says contributions to operators’ costs must never be nil. Germany has the most specific requirements, with a per-item rate card.
The newest law is the EU’s e-Evidence Regulation, which leaves reimbursement to the issuing state’s own law. Brad put it this way: each state can decide whether to permit it. So far, he said, roughly a third of the member states allow it for some providers. For the deadlines the regulation sets, see How long do you have to answer an EU e-Evidence order?
Why Brad thinks a legal standard matters
For many types of requests, Brad said, there is a legal standard for reimbursement, even if it is not exceptionally well-defined. He then gave an opinion and labeled it as one: “if you’re asking my opinion, this is a good thing.”
His reason is that a company that fails to invest sufficient resources in a law enforcement response program could cause delays, and those delays affect law enforcement’s ability to disrupt and solve criminal activity. He added that the impact reaches the reputation of law enforcement and of the companies that often hold the data.
Four questions for your counsel
Brad put it plainly: “I’m not your lawyer.” This page is his account of the law and is not legal advice. He offered four quick questions to work through with your counsel:
- What type of legal process does your company receive?
- Does the underlying law permit cost recovery, and is your company eligible?
- Do you have the infrastructure in place to identify the costs and invoice the government?
- And what are the costs and benefits for implementing a reimbursement program?
Kodex’s cost recovery page has more on the subject.
In Brad’s words
First, let’s talk about the legal history behind who pays when the government compels the work. Believe it or not, the history in the US goes back over 50 years. In 1968, Congress enacted the Wiretap Act. Two years later, an amendment said a company compelled to provide facilities or technical assistance would be compensated, and as a lawyer, I have to quote the law, “at the prevailing rates.” Almost two decades later, Congress passed the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, and with it, the Stored Communications Act. Under the new law, a government entity that obtains data under it, and I quote again, “shall pay a fee,” in most cases to cover the provider’s reasonably necessary costs. I could find little in the record that says why Congress wrote the reimbursement provision into the law. It’s fair to presume lawmakers appreciated what responding would cost companies and wanted to cover part of it.
That’s the history in the US. Abroad, the picture’s uneven. The Investigatory Powers Act in the UK says the contributions to operators’ costs, and I’m going to quote again, “must never be nil.” Germany has the most specific requirements, and has a per-item rate card. The latest one can be found within the EU’s e-Evidence Regulation. It leaves reimbursement to the issuing state’s own law, so each state can decide whether to permit reimbursements. So far, roughly a third of the member states do allow it for some providers.
That’s what the law says. For many types of requests, there is a legal standard for reimbursement, even if it’s not exceptionally well-defined. If you’re asking my opinion, this is a good thing. If a company fails to invest sufficient resources in a law enforcement response program, there could be delays impacting the ability of law enforcement to detect, to disrupt, and to solve criminal activity. That can affect the reputation of law enforcement, and also the reputation of companies who often hold the data that is key to solving or stopping crime.
At this point, you might be wondering, “Is this something we should explore?” I’m not your lawyer, but here are a few quick questions to work through with your counsel. What type of legal process does your company receive? Does the underlying law permit cost recovery, and is your company eligible? Do you have the infrastructure in place to identify the costs and invoice the government? And what are the costs and benefits of implementing a reimbursement program?
Edited for length and clarity. From the Kodex Global Keynote, October 27, 2026