Why do investigations stall on legal process?

Kevin Metcalf: So for our listeners, and I’m assuming a lot of these are investigators, I always tell them, “You really need to work on your foundational skills. Look at what you’re doing and make sure you’re executing all of your basic foundational investigative skills, and you’re doing it at a high level.” Use things like Kodex where everything is really highly professional and focused. Look for the ways that you can execute consistently that foundation. Execute it consistently at a high level and really focus on developing that.

Kevin Metcalf: You know, the advanced stuff will come. And a lot of the advanced stuff is just doing that right. Quite honestly, a lot of the investigations I’ve been involved in, probably 98% of them, we’re going back and saying, “Oh, you just missed this one thing.” “That didn’t get in. You didn’t serve legal process here and get this information ’cause you didn’t know to ask that question,” and that solves the case.

Kevin Metcalf, Founder, National Child Protection Task Force

The Bridge, recorded at IACP 2026 · October 26, 2026

Kevin’s advice to investigators

Kevin Metcalf is the founder of the National Child Protection Task Force and a former air marshal. On The Bridge, the Kodex podcast, host AJ Iafrate of Kodex asked him for his parting thoughts for the audience. Kevin assumes many of the listeners are investigators, and he spoke to them directly. Everything on this page is his own account.

Kevin says he always tells investigators to work on their foundational skills. He wants them to look at what they’re doing and confirm they are carrying out “all of your basic foundational investigative skills” at a high level. He says the advanced skills follow from that, and that “a lot of the advanced stuff is just doing that right.”

“Look at what you’re doing and make sure you’re executing all of your basic foundational investigative skills, and you’re doing it at a high level.”

Kevin Metcalf, Founder, National Child Protection Task Force

The 98% estimate

Kevin puts a number on it and gives it as his own estimate. Of the investigations he has been involved in, “probably 98%” of them came down to going back and finding that “you just missed this one thing.”

His example is legal process. In his telling, the information never came in because the investigator didn’t serve legal process for it, and the investigator didn’t serve it because they “didn’t know to ask that question.” Once that is fixed, he says, “that solves the case.”

Where Kodex fits

Kevin also tells investigators to use “things like Kodex,” where he says everything is “highly professional and focused.” His advice is to find ways to execute that foundation consistently at a high level, and to put steady effort into developing it.

What it means for a response team

Kevin speaks to investigators, and his answer shows how a case can lose ground at the request stage: the investigator didn’t know what to ask. A company’s legal response team sees the other end of that. How do investigators find where to serve legal process? looks at finding the way in, and What should a law enforcement data request include? looks at what a request holds. For the time a response takes, see Why does a slow subpoena response hurt an investigation?.

The full conversation is on The Bridge, the Kodex podcast.

In Kevin’s words

For our listeners, and I’m assuming a lot of them are investigators, I always tell them, “You really need to work on your foundational skills. Look at what you’re doing and make sure you’re executing all of your basic foundational investigative skills, and you’re doing it at a high level.” Use things like Kodex, where everything is highly professional and focused. Look for the ways that you can execute that foundation consistently at a high level, and focus on developing it.

The advanced stuff will come, and a lot of the advanced stuff is doing that right. A lot of the investigations I’ve been involved in, probably 98% of them, we’re going back and saying, “Oh, you missed this one thing. That didn’t get in. You didn’t serve legal process here and get this information because you didn’t know to ask that question,” and that solves the case.

Edited for length and clarity. From The Bridge, recorded at IACP 2026, October 26, 2026

More questions

See what
we can do
for you.

Request a demo