Why does a slow subpoena response hurt an investigation?

Carlos Verdoni: We have to protect the citizens of the country, all countries really if you think about it, ’cause it’s global. And the only way to do that is to get on a platform that actually cares to make sure everybody’s identified correctly, that they’re not fake emails, and to be able to communicate and get things done quicker.

Carlos Verdoni: Waiting for a subpoena for over five days should be too much. Right? You should have it within hours, but let’s just go ahead and give them the five days. 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, companies that I’m talking about, you know who you are. That’s ridiculous. We can’t have that. People are suffering.

Carlos Verdoni: Think of, again, going back, you and I are passionate about victims. I know that ’cause of all of our conversations we had. Those 60, 30, 90 days, you’re not helping any victim. And you can pound your chest and be like, “Oh, yeah, we’re responding,” but three months later doesn’t help.

Carlos Verdoni, Retired Detective, Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office

The Bridge, recorded at IACP 2026 · October 26, 2026

Carlos Verdoni’s view

Carlos Verdoni is a retired Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office detective and now works at TRM Labs. He spoke with AJ Iafrate on The Bridge, the Kodex podcast. What follows is his own view.

Carlos starts from protection. He says the citizens of the country have to be protected, “all countries really if you think about it.” The way to do it, in his view, is “to get on a platform that actually cares to make sure everybody’s identified correctly” and to communicate and get things done quicker.

How long he says a subpoena should take

Carlos says that waiting on a subpoena for more than five days is too much, and that an investigator should have the reply within hours. He is willing to give companies the five days.

“Waiting for a subpoena for over five days should be too much.”

Carlos Verdoni, Retired Detective, Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office

He then names the longer waits: 30 days, 60 days, 90 days. Of the companies he means, he says “you know who you are.” He calls those waits “ridiculous” and says, “People are suffering.”

A reply that comes too late

Carlos says a slow reply helps no victim. A company can “pound your chest” and say it is responding, he says, but “three months later doesn’t help.” He ties the point to victims. Carlos says he and AJ are passionate about them, and that waits of 60, 30 or 90 days do not help any victim.

What it means for a legal response team

Carlos speaks as an investigator who waits on these replies. For a legal response team, his answer shows how that wait looks from the other side of the request: he wants replies within hours, and he says a reply three months later doesn’t help. How fast should a legal team resolve a law enforcement request? is the Kodex answer on pace, and How quickly should you respond to an emergency data request? covers the urgent cases. For where cases lose ground earlier, see Why do investigations stall on legal process?.

The full conversation is on The Bridge, the Kodex podcast.

In Carlos’s words

We have to protect the citizens of the country, all countries really if you think about it, because it’s global. The only way to do that is to get on a platform that cares to make sure everybody’s identified correctly, that they’re not fake emails, and to be able to communicate and get things done quicker.

Waiting for a subpoena for over five days should be too much. You should have it within hours, but let’s go ahead and give them the five days. As for 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, the companies I’m talking about know who they are. That’s ridiculous. We can’t have that. People are suffering.

Those 60, 30, 90 days, you’re not helping any victim. You can pound your chest and say, “Oh, yeah, we’re responding,” but three months later doesn’t help.

Edited for length and clarity. From The Bridge, recorded at IACP 2026, October 26, 2026

More questions

See what
we can do
for you.

Request a demo