In federal court, Rule 45 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure governs these subpoenas. A litigant who needs records held by a provider serves one on the provider, and the company receives a demand from a private party with no agency behind it.
The Stored Communications Act applies to that demand as it applies to a prosecutor’s, and it decides which of the provider’s data a private litigant can reach.
Who issues it and where it reaches
Under Rule 45(a)(3), the clerk issues a signed blank subpoena to a party who requests it, and an attorney authorised to practice in the issuing court can also issue and sign one. For a subpoena that commands production of documents, Rule 45(a)(4) requires notice and a copy to each party before service on the recipient.
Production can be required within 100 miles of where the recipient resides, is employed or regularly transacts business in person (Rule 45(c)(2)(A)).
What the Stored Communications Act allows
Under 18 U.S.C. § 2702(a), a provider that offers service to the public shall not knowingly divulge the contents of communications to any person or entity. The exceptions in § 2702(b) include none for civil discovery. In In re Subpoena Duces Tecum to AOL, LLC, 550 F. Supp. 2d 606 (E.D. Va. 2008), the court upheld an order quashing a civil subpoena for a non-party’s email because no exception in the statute covers civil discovery.
Records other than contents sit under a different rule. Section 2702(c)(6) permits a provider to disclose them to any person other than a governmental entity, and a private litigant is such a person. Contents can move with lawful consent under § 2702(b)(3). Under the Stored Communications Act, a litigant seeking contents turns to the account holder.
| Civil subpoena | Criminal subpoena | |
|---|---|---|
| Who issues it | Clerk or an attorney authorised to practice in the issuing court (Rule 45(a)(3)) | Clerk, in blank, under Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(a); § 2703 also names administrative and grand jury subpoenas |
| Content of communications | Barred. No § 2702(b) exception covers civil discovery. | Section 2703(b) provides a subpoena route for certain contents, with prior notice to the subscriber |
| Non-content records | Permitted under § 2702(c)(6) | Basic subscriber information under § 2703(c)(2) |
| Objection deadline | Before the earlier of the compliance time or 14 days after service (Rule 45(d)(2)(B)) | A motion made promptly (Rule 17(c)(2)) |
Objecting and quashing
A person commanded to produce documents serves a written objection on the party or attorney named in the subpoena. The objection must be served before the earlier of the time set for compliance or 14 days after service (Rule 45(d)(2)(B)). On a timely motion, the court for the district where compliance is required must quash or modify a subpoena that allows too little time, reaches beyond the geographic limits of Rule 45(c), requires disclosure of privileged or other protected matter or subjects the person to undue burden (Rule 45(d)(3)(A)).
Notice to the account holder
Rule 45 requires notice to the parties in the case, and its text sets no notice duty toward an account holder who is not a party. Telling that person is a user notice decision for the provider. Section 2705(b) lets a governmental entity acting under § 2703 apply for an order barring notice, and it names no private litigant.