In the United States, the Stored Communications Act puts the notice duties it creates on the government. Whether a provider tells its own user about a request is a matter of the provider’s policy, within the limits of any non-disclosure order that applies.
Who owes notice under the statute
Section 2703 puts notice duties on the governmental entity. For contents held by a remote computing service, a governmental entity using an administrative, grand jury or trial subpoena, or a § 2703(d) order, gives the subscriber prior notice (§ 2703(b)(1)(B)). A warrant carries no required notice (§ 2703(b)(1)(A)). A governmental entity receiving records under § 2703(c) is not required to give notice (§ 2703(c)(3)).
Section 2705(a) lets the government delay the notice § 2703(b) requires for up to 90 days, on a court order or on a written certification by a supervisory official, with extensions of up to 90 days each. A civil subpoena comes from a private litigant, and § 2705 gives a private litigant no way to bar notice of it.
What blocks notice
A non-disclosure order under 18 U.S.C. § 2705(b) directs a provider not to notify any other person of the existence of a warrant, subpoena or court order, for such period as the court deems appropriate. The court enters the order if it finds reason to believe that notice will endanger an individual, lead to flight from prosecution, destroy or tamper with evidence, intimidate witnesses or otherwise seriously jeopardise an investigation or unduly delay a trial. A Department of Justice policy from October 2017, supplemented in May 2022, directs prosecutors to seek orders of one year or less, absent exceptional circumstances.
A national security letter carries its own bar. Under 18 U.S.C. § 2709(c), once the Director of the FBI or a qualifying designee certifies that one of the harms the statute lists is at stake and notice of judicial review is provided, the recipient does not disclose that the FBI sought or obtained the information. The recipient can still tell the people needed to comply and an attorney.
| Can the provider tell the user? | Until when | |
|---|---|---|
| Subpoena with no gag | Yes. No order bars it, and the provider’s policy decides. | No end date applies |
| Process with a § 2705(b) order | No | The end of the period the court set |
| National security letter | No, once the certification and the notice of judicial review are in place | Until the requirement ends. It is subject to judicial review under 18 U.S.C. § 3511 (§ 2709(d)). |
| European Production Order | The issuing authority informs the person, and the addressee keeps the order certificate confidential | The issuing authority sets any delay under national law (Article 13) |
The EU position
Article 13 of Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 gives the duty to the issuing authority. It informs the person whose data are requested, without undue delay, and includes information about available remedies. The authority can delay or restrict the notice, or omit it, under national law, for as long as the conditions in Article 13(3) of Directive (EU) 2016/680 are met. The addressee takes measures that protect the confidentiality of the certificate and of the data produced.