Every instrument has limits. A subpoena reaches the records the statute lists for it, and a warrant reaches what it particularly describes. A request that goes past those limits is overbroad, and the scope of responsive records is the question the company answers before it produces anything.
What overbreadth looks like
| What it looks like | Basis for narrowing | |
|---|---|---|
| Too many accounts | The request names more accounts than the matter connects to the investigation | Particularity for a warrant; undue burden for an order or a civil subpoena |
| Too long a period | The date range runs beyond what the matter justifies | Unreasonable or oppressive (Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(c)(2)); unusually voluminous (§ 2703(d)) |
| Wrong instrument for the data | A subpoena asks for records beyond the list in § 2703(c)(2) | Section 2703(c)(1) calls for a warrant or a § 2703(d) order for those records |
| Vague description | The request does not identify the account or the records with precision | Warrants must particularly describe the place to be searched and the things to be seized |
The legal bases for objecting
- Warrants. The Fourth Amendment provides that no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.
- Criminal subpoenas. On motion made promptly, the court can quash or modify a subpoena if compliance would be unreasonable or oppressive (Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(c)(2)).
- Civil subpoenas. The court for the district where compliance is required must quash or modify a subpoena that subjects a person to undue burden (Fed. R. Civ. P. 45(d)(3)(A)(iv)). Rule 45(d)(1) requires the issuing party to take reasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense.
- Section 2703(d) orders. On a motion made promptly by the service provider, the court can quash or modify an order if the records requested are unusually voluminous or compliance would otherwise cause an undue burden.
What a provider does about one
A provider that receives an overbroad request has three routes.
- Ask the requester to narrow it.
- Produce the part that the instrument supports and record what was left out and why.
- Move to quash or modify, within the time the governing rule allows.
For a subpoena, the motion has to come promptly under Rule 17(c)(2), and a civil subpoena carries the 14-day objection window in Rule 45(d)(2)(B).
Why producing beyond scope is a risk
Section 2702(a) bars a provider from divulging stored contents, and it bars disclosure of subscriber records to a governmental entity, outside the listed exceptions. Section 2703(e) protects a provider that provides information in accordance with the terms of a court order, warrant, subpoena, statutory authorisation or certification. A production past those terms falls outside that protection.
Under § 2707(a), a subscriber aggrieved by a violation committed with a knowing or intentional state of mind can bring a civil action, and § 2707(c) sets damages of at least $1,000 for a plaintiff entitled to recover. Section 2707(e) makes good-faith reliance on a court warrant or order, a grand jury subpoena, a legislative authorization or a statutory authorization a complete defence.