Investigators who serve a geofence warrant start from a place and a time. The warrant asks the provider to identify the devices that were there.
The Supreme Court decided Chatrie v. United States on June 29, 2026, and the case went back to the Fourth Circuit for further proceedings.
What a geofence warrant asks for
The warrant in Chatrie covered a 150-metre radius around a credit union that had been robbed. It described three steps:
- The provider produces anonymised location data for all cell phones inside the geofence from 30 minutes before to 30 minutes after the robbery.
- Officers narrow the list, and the provider produces additional anonymised data for the narrowed list, covering locations inside and outside the geofence over a two-hour period.
- Officers narrow the list again, and the provider produces identifying information, including names and phone numbers, for the final list.
Why courts treat them as a Fourth Amendment question
A search warrant issues only when probable cause is established and the scope of the search is set out with particularity, as the Supreme Court restated in Chatrie. A geofence warrant gathers location data about everyone in the area. That raises the question whether probable cause and particularity hold for each device the warrant sweeps in.
Carpenter v. United States, 585 U.S. 296, decided June 22, 2018, held that acquiring historical cell-site records is a search. The Court said the Government must generally obtain a warrant supported by probable cause.
Where the courts stand
- Fifth Circuit, United States v. Smith, August 9, 2024. The court held that geofence warrants, at least as described in its opinion, are unconstitutional under the Fourth Amendment. It affirmed the denial of suppression because law enforcement had acted in good faith.
- Fourth Circuit, Chatrie, 2024 and 2025. A divided panel held in 2024 that no search occurred. On April 30, 2025, the full court affirmed in a one-sentence per curiam opinion and divided evenly on whether a search occurred.
- Supreme Court, Chatrie, June 29, 2026. The Court held that police conducted a Fourth Amendment search when they acquired the location data. It vacated the Fourth Circuit’s judgment and remanded, for that court to decide whether the warrant met the particularity and probable cause requirements at each step. The Court granted review only on the search question, so it did not decide whether the good-faith exception applies.
How it compares and what a provider reviews
| Search warrant for an account | Geofence warrant | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | A known account or person | A place and a time window |
| Who is covered | The named account holder | Every device recorded in the area during the window |
| What defines scope | The account and the data categories listed | The area, the time window and the steps listed |
| Main legal question | Probable cause to search that account | Probable cause and particularity for the devices swept in |
A provider that receives a geofence warrant checks the size of the area, the length of the time window and the steps the warrant lists. It also confirms which data each step releases. A warrant whose area or window looks wider than its probable cause supports raises the questions covered under overbroad requests.